docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers

doc/bug_analysis.md

@@ -1,19 +1,26 @@
 # Open issues
 
-## Issue16: First CurrentDemandReq is rejected with FAILED_SequenceError and EVSE_Shutdown
+## Issue 17: Welding detection fails
-- observed on Alpitronics HPC with version v0.4-6-g257e5af
+- WeldingDetectionRes says "failed" on alpitronics, and no response on ABBHPC and ABBTriple
-- log 2022-12-20_alpi_currentDemandSequenceErrorShutdown.pcapng
+- version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
-- same result in two trys
 
 ## Issue15: After end of PreCharging, the log says "re-initializing fsmPev"
 - observed with v0.4 on the Compleo charger
 - PreCharge target voltage is reached. The fsmPev sends a message
 01fe800100000012809a022189cbf75b9625a9513022800a0800
 and after one second the state machine seems to run into timeout.
-
+- to be retested. Most likely fixed with with v0.4-7-g7cea8b5.
 
 # Closed issues
 
+## [Solved] Issue16: First CurrentDemandReq is rejected with FAILED_SequenceError and EVSE_Shutdown
+- observed on Alpitronics HPC with version v0.4-6-g257e5af
+- log 2022-12-20_alpi_currentDemandSequenceErrorShutdown.pcapng
+- same result in two trys
+- root cause: In the exi encoder, the PowerDeliveryReq.ReadyToChargeState was treated as enum as in the ISO, but in fact it must be boolean.
+- Fixed with https://github.com/uhi22/OpenV2Gx/commit/a00f1fba878085629a8325281b0a29c9ce6dd72c
+- Test pass 2022-12-21 with v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 on alpi, ABB HPC and ABB triple charger.
+
 ## [Solved] Issue14: Connection loss after authorization
 - with version v0.4.
 - same version works fine on Compleo

doc/charger_test_results.md

@@ -4,30 +4,7 @@
 
 Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/hagebaumarkt-Siemensstrasse-1/48209/
 
-Test results of version v0.2
+Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21, Köschinger Forst Ost)
-- [x] SLAC
-- [x] SDP
-- [x] TCP connection
-- [x] EXI
-    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
-	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
-	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
-	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
-	- [ ] DIN CableCheck
-	- [ ] DIN PreCharge
-	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery, CurrentDemand
-
-## ABB Terra HPC
-
-Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Total-Tankstelle-Ruppertswies-6/63794/
-
-Test results tbd
-
-## Alpitronic HPC HYC300
-
-Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Dehner-Garten-Center-Degenhartstrasse-Degenhartstrasse-2/71112/
-
-Test results of version v0.4-6-g257e5af
 - [x] SLAC
 - [x] SDP
 - [x] TCP connection
@@ -41,10 +18,58 @@ Test results of version v0.4-6-g257e5af
 	- [x] DIN CableCheck
 	- [x] DIN PreCharge
 	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
-	- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand rejected with FAILED_SequenceError and EVSE_Shutdown. Issue 16
+	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
-	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
-	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection
+	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection no response 2022-12-21T08:50:36.640899, issue 17
 	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
+- [x] Inlet voltage measurement
+
+## ABB Terra HPC
+
+Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Total-Tankstelle-Ruppertswies-6/63794/
+
+Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
+- [x] SLAC
+- [x] SDP
+- [x] TCP connection
+- [x] EXI
+    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
+	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
+	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
+	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
+	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN CableCheck
+	- [x] DIN PreCharge
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
+	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
+	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: No response 2022-12-21T08:36:29.943830, issue 17
+	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
+- [x] Inlet voltage measurement
+
+## Alpitronic HPC HYC300
+
+Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Dehner-Garten-Center-Degenhartstrasse-Degenhartstrasse-2/71112/
+
+Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
+- [x] SLAC
+- [x] SDP
+- [x] TCP connection
+- [x] EXI
+    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
+	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
+	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
+	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
+	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN CableCheck
+	- [x] DIN PreCharge
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
+	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
+	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: "ResponseCode": "FAILED", issue 17
+	- [ ] DIN SessionStop: No response
 - [x] Inlet voltage measurement (shows 500V during cable check, and 230V during precharge)
 
 ## Compleo Cito BM 500
@@ -70,19 +95,46 @@ Test results of version v0.4
 
 Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/Koeschinger-Forst-West-A9/15982/
 
-Test results tbd
+Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
+- [x] SLAC
+- [x] SDP
+- [x] TCP connection
+- [x] EXI
+    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
+	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
+	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
+	- [ ] DIN ContractAuthentication: Due to defective charger, no authorization possible via app or RFID.
 
 ## Efacec HPC Efapower Kiosk HV175
 
 Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Neufahrn-bei-Freising/Fuerholzen-West-A9/22771/
 
-Test results tbd
+Test tbd
 
 ## Ionity Tritium Veefil-PK
 
 Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/IONITY-Koeschinger-Forst-Ost-A9/37875/
 
-Test results tbd
+Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5
+- [x] SLAC
+- [x] SDP
+- [x] TCP connection
+- [x] EXI
+    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
+	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
+	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
+	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
+	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
+	- [x] DIN CableCheck
+	- [x] DIN PreCharge
+	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
+	- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand: With the light-bulb configuration, the charger overshoots the intended voltage, because no load is connected at the start of the charging loop. Then, after a few seconds, the charger stops.
+	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
+	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection
+	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
+- [x] Inlet voltage measurement
 
 ## Porsche
 

doc/todo.md

@@ -2,9 +2,10 @@
 
 - [x] Decode CableCheckRes."DC_EVSEStatus.EVSEStatusCode": dinDC_EVSEStatusCodeType as readable text
 - [ ] Decode CableCheckRes."DC_EVSEStatus.EVSEIsolationStatus": dinisolationLevelType as readable text
-- [ ] Encoder: PreChargeReq: is it possible to enable the units for EVTargetVoltage and EVTargetCurrent?
+- [x] Encoder: PreChargeReq: is it possible to enable the units for EVTargetVoltage and EVTargetCurrent?
-- [ ] Find out, why Alpi reports CableCheckRes = Finished FAILED in v0.4
+- [x] Encoder: CurrentDemandReq: is it possible to enable the units for EVTargetVoltage and EVTargetCurrent?
-- [ ] Find out, why Compleo ignores the PowerDeliveryReq START in v0.4
+- [x] Find out, why Alpi reports CableCheckRes = Finished FAILED in v0.4
+- [x] Find out, why Compleo ignores the PowerDeliveryReq START in v0.4
 - [x] Add date/time into ExiLog
 - [ ] PevMode: Add state transition in case of failed CableCheck
 - [x] PevMode: PreChargeReq: Fill EVRESSSOC, EVTargetVoltage, EVTargetCurrent

readme.md

@@ -305,6 +305,10 @@ hardware side. Without the load, we see the intended 230V precharge voltage, and
 - The Alpi confirms the PowerDelivery (start), but rejects the CurrentDemandRequest with FAILED_SequenceError and EVSE_Shutdown.
 - Results (log file and pcap) are stored in https://github.com/uhi22/pyPLC/tree/master/results.
 
+### 2022-12-21 v0.5 Light-bulb-demo-charging works on multiple chargers
+- On 3 of 4 tested charger models, the light-bulb-demo works: AlpitronicHPC, ABB HPC, ABB Triple. The Ionity Tritium overshoots the target voltage due to missing load, and aborts.
+- Welding detection gives negative or no answer.
+
 ### Test results on real-world chargers
 
 See [charger_test_results.md](doc/charger_test_results.md)