pyPLC/doc/charger_test_results.md

# Test Results on different Real-World Chargers

## ABB Terra 53 Triple Charger

Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/hagebaumarkt-Siemensstrasse-1/48209/

Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21, Köschinger Forst Ost)
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [x] DIN CableCheck
	- [x] DIN PreCharge
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection no response 2022-12-21T08:50:36.640899, issue 17
	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
- [x] Inlet voltage measurement

## ABB Terra HPC

Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Total-Tankstelle-Ruppertswies-6/63794/

Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [x] DIN CableCheck
	- [x] DIN PreCharge
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: No response 2022-12-21T08:36:29.943830, issue 17
	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
- [x] Inlet voltage measurement

## Alpitronic HPC HYC300

Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Dehner-Garten-Center-Degenhartstrasse-Degenhartstrasse-2/71112/

Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [x] DIN CableCheck
	- [x] DIN PreCharge
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
	- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: "ResponseCode": "FAILED", issue 17
	- [ ] DIN SessionStop: No response
- [x] Inlet voltage measurement (shows 500V during cable check, and 230V during precharge)

## Circontrol

First test negative, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56268#p56268.
The SLAC works, but after SetKey we do not see the chargers modem.

## Compleo Cito BM 500

Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/EDEKA-Ingolstaedter-Strasse-114/62619/

Test results of version v0.7 (2023-04-19)
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [x] DIN CableCheck (10s loop ongoing, then finished OK)
	- [x] DIN PreCharge
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery
      [x] DIN CurrentDemand: With no load and later light bulb connected, the charger has massive problems to regulate the voltage. It shoots over to 400V and later turns off completely, instead of regulating to the target 230V. Log: results/2023-04-19_compleo_pyPlc_lightbulb_failedBadRegulation.pcapng and 2023-04-19_compleo_pyPlc_lightbulb_failedBadRegulation.pcapng.decoded.txt

## Efacec QC45 Triple Charger

Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/Koeschinger-Forst-West-A9/15982/

Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [ ] DIN ContractAuthentication: Due to defective charger, no authorization possible via app or RFID.

## Efacec HPC Efapower Kiosk HV175

Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Neufahrn-bei-Freising/Fuerholzen-West-A9/22771/

Test tbd

## Ionity Tritium Veefil-PK

Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/IONITY-Koeschinger-Forst-Ost-A9/37875/

Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [x] DIN CableCheck
	- [x] DIN PreCharge
	- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start
	- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand: With the light-bulb configuration, the charger overshoots the intended voltage, because no load is connected at the start of the charging loop. Then, after a few seconds, the charger stops.
	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection
	- [ ] DIN SessionStop
- [x] Inlet voltage measurement

## Kempower satellite

Tested by celeron55 with his fork https://github.com/celeron55/pyPLC 2023-05-03.

Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56188&sid=9579fd29268d0e332c81ed528f59f09b#p56188

## Porsche

Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Audi-Forum-Ettinger-Strasse/7970/

Test results tbd

## Siemens

Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56478#p56478

## Tesla Supercharger V2

Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56478#p56478

## Tesla Supercharger V3

Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Supercharger-Car-Wash-Ruppertswies-4/69557/
or https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Pfaffenhofen-an-der-Ilm/Supercharger-Hotel-Strasshof-Siebenecken-1/44134/

Test results of version v0.5-12-g23b1384, on 2023-03-02
- [x] SLAC
- [x] SDP
- [x] TCP connection
- [x] EXI
    - [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol
	- [x] DIN SessionSetup
	- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery
	- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection
	- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication
	- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery
	- [ ] DIN CableCheck: The cable check runs into timeout. No real voltage on the pins. Maybe caused by wrong sessionId, see issue 18.
	- [ ] DIN PreCharge
	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Start
	- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand
	- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop
	- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection
	- [ ] DIN SessionStop

## Tritium 75kW

Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56268#p56268
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`# Test Results on different Real-World Chargers`

			`## ABB Terra 53 Triple Charger`

			`Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/hagebaumarkt-Siemensstrasse-1/48209/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21, Köschinger Forst Ost)`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`- [x] DIN CableCheck`
			`- [x] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start`
			`- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop`
			`- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection no response 2022-12-21T08:50:36.640899, issue 17`
			`- [ ] DIN SessionStop`
			`- [x] Inlet voltage measurement`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
			`## ABB Terra HPC`

			`Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Total-Tankstelle-Ruppertswies-6/63794/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)`
			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN CableCheck`
			`- [x] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start`
			`- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop`
			`- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: No response 2022-12-21T08:36:29.943830, issue 17`
			`- [ ] DIN SessionStop`
			`- [x] Inlet voltage measurement`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
			`## Alpitronic HPC HYC300`

			`Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Dehner-Garten-Center-Degenhartstrasse-Degenhartstrasse-2/71112/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
PevMode: added contractAuthentication 2022-12-02 12:02:40 +00:00			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
docu: test results on Alpitronics 2022-12-20 11:43:06 +00:00			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
PevMode: added contractAuthentication 2022-12-02 12:02:40 +00:00			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
docu: test results on Alpitronics 2022-12-20 11:43:06 +00:00			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN CableCheck`
			`- [x] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start`
docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`- [x] DIN CurrentDemand: Light bulb demo works`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Stop`
			`- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection: "ResponseCode": "FAILED", issue 17`
			`- [ ] DIN SessionStop: No response`
docu: test results on Alpitronics 2022-12-20 11:43:06 +00:00			`- [x] Inlet voltage measurement (shows 500V during cable check, and 230V during precharge)`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
docu: added charger test results and todos 2023-05-13 19:15:39 +00:00			`## Circontrol`

			`First test negative, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56268#p56268.`
			`The SLAC works, but after SetKey we do not see the chargers modem.`

added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`## Compleo Cito BM 500`

			`Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/EDEKA-Ingolstaedter-Strasse-114/62619/`

docu: test results and release v0.7 2023-04-19 18:53:03 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.7 (2023-04-19)`
docu: v0.4 progress documented 2022-12-13 20:52:16 +00:00			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN CableCheck (10s loop ongoing, then finished OK)`
docu: test results and release v0.7 2023-04-19 18:53:03 +00:00			`- [x] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery`
			`[x] DIN CurrentDemand: With no load and later light bulb connected, the charger has massive problems to regulate the voltage. It shoots over to 400V and later turns off completely, instead of regulating to the target 230V. Log: results/2023-04-19_compleo_pyPlc_lightbulb_failedBadRegulation.pcapng and 2023-04-19_compleo_pyPlc_lightbulb_failedBadRegulation.pcapng.decoded.txt`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
			`## Efacec QC45 Triple Charger`

			`Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/Koeschinger-Forst-West-A9/15982/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5 (2022-12-21)`
			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [ ] DIN ContractAuthentication: Due to defective charger, no authorization possible via app or RFID.`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
			`## Efacec HPC Efapower Kiosk HV175`

			`Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Neufahrn-bei-Freising/Fuerholzen-West-A9/22771/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test tbd`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
			`## Ionity Tritium Veefil-PK`

			`Test site: e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Hepberg/IONITY-Koeschinger-Forst-Ost-A9/37875/`

docu: status of v0.5, light-bulb-demo works on 3 of 4 chargers 2022-12-21 09:55:26 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.4-7-g7cea8b5`
			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN CableCheck`
			`- [x] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [x] DIN PowerDelivery Start`
			`- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand: With the light-bulb configuration, the charger overshoots the intended voltage, because no load is connected at the start of the charging loop. Then, after a few seconds, the charger stops.`
			`- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop`
			`- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection`
			`- [ ] DIN SessionStop`
			`- [x] Inlet voltage measurement`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
docu: results of celeron55 and todos 2023-05-03 19:44:15 +00:00			`## Kempower satellite`

			`Tested by celeron55 with his fork https://github.com/celeron55/pyPLC 2023-05-03.`

			`Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56188&sid=9579fd29268d0e332c81ed528f59f09b#p56188`

added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`## Porsche`

			`Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Ingolstadt/Audi-Forum-Ettinger-Strasse/7970/`

			`Test results tbd`

docu: added charger test results and todos 2023-05-13 19:15:39 +00:00			`## Siemens`

			`Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56478#p56478`

			`## Tesla Supercharger V2`

			`Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56478#p56478`

added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00			`## Tesla Supercharger V3`

			`Test site e.g. https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Koesching/Supercharger-Car-Wash-Ruppertswies-4/69557/`
added supercharger test results 2023-03-02 20:32:41 +00:00			`or https://www.goingelectric.de/stromtankstellen/Deutschland/Pfaffenhofen-an-der-Ilm/Supercharger-Hotel-Strasshof-Siebenecken-1/44134/`
added charger_test_results.md 2022-11-30 17:56:35 +00:00
added supercharger test results 2023-03-02 20:32:41 +00:00			`Test results of version v0.5-12-g23b1384, on 2023-03-02`
			`- [x] SLAC`
			`- [x] SDP`
			`- [x] TCP connection`
			`- [x] EXI`
			`- [x] DIN SupportedApplicationProtocol`
			`- [x] DIN SessionSetup`
			`- [x] DIN ServiceDiscovery`
			`- [x] DIN ServicePaymentSelection`
			`- [x] DIN ContractAuthentication`
			`- [x] DIN ChargeParameterDiscovery`
			`- [ ] DIN CableCheck: The cable check runs into timeout. No real voltage on the pins. Maybe caused by wrong sessionId, see issue 18.`
			`- [ ] DIN PreCharge`
			`- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Start`
			`- [ ] DIN CurrentDemand`
			`- [ ] DIN PowerDelivery Stop`
			`- [ ] DIN WeldingDetection`
			`- [ ] DIN SessionStop`
docu updated with latest knowledge 2022-12-01 15:37:41 +00:00
docu: added charger test results and todos 2023-05-13 19:15:39 +00:00			`## Tritium 75kW`

			`Charging works, see https://openinverter.org/forum/viewtopic.php?p=56268#p56268`